Testing 12 different Zigbee temperature/humidity sensors

(smarthomescene.com)

25 points | by walrus01 1 day ago

3 comments

  • kadoban 1 day ago
    Do _not_ get the Aqara ones. The things will not stay connected for shit.

    I have a couple of the Tuya ones and I'm pleased with them. The humidity accuracy is questionable, but it's fine.

    I also have an airgradient (not zigbee, uses wifi) for high accuracy the one place I care about that. Works great in Home Assistant with esphome.

    • nijave 16 minutes ago
      Hmm interesting I have 4-5 of them and quite like them. They've all stayed connected over a year except 1 which I just replaced the battery in and I think that fixed it. It was reporting 40% battery but would drop off shortly after connecting.

      Aqara might be the ones with a crappy ZigBee implementation that doesn't roam right so if you move them or your topology changes, they'll drop off.

    • cmckn 56 minutes ago
      > Do _not_ get the Aqara ones. The things will not stay connected for shit.

      +1, complete waste of time and money. I thought my Zigbee network or HA was the problem, but the sensors are just garbage.

      • parineum 40 minutes ago
        It's a known issue with them that they don't ever change their routing. If you connect them in a different place than you use them, you're going to have suboptimal to unusable routes.
  • cyberax 58 minutes ago
    Hah. I did something similar a while ago, but I also did full saturated salt solution humidity calibration. It's very simple to do: get several different salts, create a saturated solution in a sealed container, and observe the humidity there.

    The best sensor in my tests was CentraLite 3310-G. It was the only one actually precise to 1% of RH and 0.1C They are also pretty robust and long-lasting.

  • nh2 1 hour ago
    [dead]