6 comments

  • florianherrengt 1 hour ago
    This paper puts words to something I’ve noticed repeatedly with LLMs, particularly Qwen3.6. When I read its reasoning, it appears to recognise the mistake and then carry on as if it hadn’t noticed it at all.

    > models often determine their answers based on implicit biases tied to question templates, then construct reasoning chains to justify their predetermined conclusions > its reasoning was correct right until the final step (Yes/No answer)

    • Georgelemental 1 hour ago
      Natural intelligences do this too
      • tyg13 56 minutes ago
        Must we always see this restated every time? It's getting a bit stale always seeing these kinds of comments on articles about LLM.
        • uludag 4 minutes ago
          I can just immagine the response to a headline "LLM chooses mass death: thousands killed in horrific AI accident" being something like "lots of humans have caused mass death too."
        • cyanydeez 25 minutes ago
          You think, "this problem" is qn LLM problem?
      • phailhaus 38 minutes ago
        No they don't, human intelligence has the ability to form an internal model of itself, which allows it to "notice" its own mistakes and change.
        • cyanydeez 24 minutes ago
          Many who watched the last decade knows just because its possible to noticed mistakes and change, its clearly not a reliable process.
          • elictronic 1 minute ago
            The current political climate is well reasoned and intentional. It might not be yours or mine, however the system is working exactly as the ones paying for it have intended.
      • freejazz 58 minutes ago
        Yeah and it's not great then either
    • paimapi 45 minutes ago
      [dead]
  • ForHackernews 38 minutes ago
    I thought this was already widely known?

    From March last year: https://transformer-circuits.pub/2025/attribution-graphs/bio...

    There's no reason to believe the model's self-reported "thinking" bears any relation to the mechanics by which it arrived at some output.

  • kibwen 1 hour ago
    "Study: Communing With The Gods of Mount Olympus Via the Oracle at Delphi Is Not Always Faithful"
  • nemomarx 1 hour ago
    [dead]
  • josefritzishere 1 hour ago
    [flagged]