The Real Story of Troy

(storica.club)

16 points | by cemsakarya 2 days ago

1 comments

  • ge96 1 hour ago
    I was disappointed the horse wasn't real
    • moomin 44 minutes ago
      Ben Bova hypothesized that Homer was actually describing early siege towers, but given the veracity of many mundane parts of the story it seems unlikely.
      • detourdog 11 minutes ago
        I have also heard it described as a boat.
    • readthenotes1 47 minutes ago
      How do you know? It was mentioned by Homer, wasn't it?
      • huxley 38 minutes ago
        At least not in the Iliad though it gets short mentions in the Odyssey.

        Most of what we know of it appeared in non-Homeric stories and most famously (nowadays) in Virgil.

        • elmomle 11 minutes ago
          That is so, but my understanding was that those later stories tie back to a lost epic (Iliupersis) that, while not officially attributed to Homer, was being sung contemporaneously with the other stories of the Trojan war cycle.
      • ge96 43 minutes ago
        I don't just online consensus. Need to simulate the universe's particles and rewind time like that show Devs to witness it myself.
      • jsharpe 45 minutes ago
        We don't even know if Homer was real. XD
        • moomin 37 minutes ago
          I’ve seen it fairly convincingly argued that he wasn’t!